HP 61XL Black InkWorth it, if your printer matches
around $50Check price

Is HP 61XL Black Ink Worth It?

HP — Is HP 61XL Black Ink Worth It?

Worth it, if your printer matches

4/5 our verdict score

around $50price at time of review — check Amazon for current

  • Worth it ifYour printer model is on HP's 61 compatibility list
  • Skip it ifYour printer isn't one of the listed DeskJet, Envy, or OfficeJet models

Amazon shoppers rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 90,524 ratings. That is their number, not ours.

By Lena Fischer, office & workspace · updated 2026-07-29

As an Amazon Associate, Is It Worth It Reviews earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra, and it has never changed a verdict.

You hit print on the school permission slip five minutes before the bus arrives, and instead of clean black text you get grey, streaky ghosts of letters. The printer icon blinks amber. That flashing light is the moment everyone with an inkjet knows, and it's exactly when you start googling something like hp ink 61xl black, wondering if the cartridge you're about to buy will actually fix it or just delay the same panic by a few weeks.

Here's the part the box doesn't spell out. An inkjet cartridge isn't just a bag of black liquid, it's a nozzle plate and a tiny chip that talks to your printer before a single drop moves. That chip tells the printer what ink is inside, how much is left, and whether it recognizes the cartridge as genuine. The XL designation just means a bigger internal reservoir than the standard cartridge, roughly 360 pages, so you're refilling less often for the same printing habits. The ink itself is water-based, formulated to sit flat on plain paper and resist fading, which is why text stays sharp and photos don't yellow sitting on a shelf. The catch is that this chip-and-nozzle pairing is model-specific: it's engineered against a defined list, DeskJet 1000 through 3510, Envy 4500 and 5530, OfficeJet 2620 and 4630, and outside that list the printer simply won't recognize it, however genuine the cartridge looks. That's also why yield numbers swing in real use, a page of dense graphics burns through ink faster than a page of double-spaced text, even from an identical cartridge.

So you're not really buying a bottle of ink, you're buying a printer's willingness to trust the cartridge you hand it. Get the right model match and a genuine chip, and the higher yield and fade resistance take care of themselves. Get either one wrong, mismatched printer or an unverified cartridge, and no amount of high-yield marketing saves the print job.

Worth it if

  • Your printer model is on HP's 61 compatibility list
  • You print mostly text documents rather than photo-heavy pages
  • You'd rather buy less often than chase the cheapest per-cartridge price

Skip it if

  • Your printer isn't one of the listed DeskJet, Envy, or OfficeJet models
  • You print high volumes and would save more with a refillable ink tank printer
  • You mainly print photos and want a dedicated photo ink set

Not for printers outside HP's listed 61 series lineup or anyone printing high volumes of photos daily

If your printer is on that compatibility list and you're mostly printing documents rather than photos, this is a quiet, sensible restock. If you're a high-volume printer or your model isn't on the list, a bulk ink tank system will treat your wallet better long term.

Check price on Amazon · around $50 or Add it to your Amazon cart to sit on it

Before you go

What is the difference between HP 61 and HP 61XL?

The XL version holds more ink in the same cartridge shell, giving roughly double the page yield of the standard 61, so you replace it less often for the same printing volume.

Is it worth buying HP XL ink cartridges?

Yes, for anyone printing regularly on a compatible model, since the lower cost per page and higher yield outweigh the modest jump in upfront price over the standard cartridge.

Is HP 61 Black ink being discontinued?

HP still manufactures and sells 61 and 61XL cartridges for its supported printer lineup, so it isn't being phased out, though the list of compatible printer models is periodically updated.

Full spec sheet
Ink ColourBlack
Page Yield360
Compatible DevicesWorks with these HP Printers OfficeJet 4635,4630,4632; ENVY 5530; DeskJet 2050,3050
Other Special Features of the ProductFade Resistant, High Yield
Compatibility OptionsOEM
ColorBlack
Cartridge TypeGenuine
Printer Model CompatibilityHP Deskjet 1000, HP Deskjet 3050A, HP Deskjet 3051A, HP Deskjet 3054A, HP Deskjet 3056A

Lena Fischer covers office & workspace for Is It Worth It Reviews. We research products and explain them honestly; we do not test them and we never pretend to.