Are Temptations Cat Treats (30oz) Worth It?
Worth it, with one check for special diets
By Sophie Vance, pet supplies · updated 2026-07-24
Worth it, if you want a daily treat that won't wreck your cat's calorie count
As an Amazon Associate, Is It Worth It Reviews earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra, and it has never changed a verdict.
You shake the tub, and before the lid's even off, your cat is at your ankles, tail up, absolutely certain something worth chasing is on its way. That reaction is the whole reason the Temptations cat treats 30oz tub of Classic Crunchy and Soft treats ends up in so many cat households. But the begging raises a quieter question: is a treat this exciting something you should actually be handing out every day?
Here's the bit that explains the begging: each treat is made with two textures baked into one bite, a light, crunchy shell wrapped around a softer center. That contrast is what makes a cat cross the room for it in a way a single-texture kibble treat doesn't. The trick that matters more, though, is the calorie math: each treat comes in under two calories, which is why you can use them as a genuine training reward, a meal topper for a picky eater, or a daily ritual without quietly overfeeding your cat the way a handful of regular food would. The formula is also built to be 100% complete and balanced for adult cats, so it's not just empty flavor, it's food a cat could technically live on. The resealable tub is the practical payoff of all that: since these are dry wafers, not moist pouches, the seal keeps them crunchy tub after tub, and keeps a determined cat's paws out of it when you're not in the room.
So the click here is simple: you're not paying for a treat, you're paying for a reward you can hand out daily without doing calorie math in your head. The crunchy shell and soft center do the persuading, the under-two-calorie count does the permission-giving, and the complete-and-balanced formula is what keeps it from being empty flavor.
Worth it if
- You want a low-calorie way to reward or train your cat daily
- You need a topper to tempt a picky eater into finishing a meal
- You want a treat that stays fresh and crunchy between uses
Skip it if
- Your cat is on a vet-prescribed or restricted diet
- You're looking for a wet or single-ingredient treat
- You want a treat with zero grain or filler content
If you want a treat that works as training currency, a topper for a fussy eater, or just a daily ritual your cat looks forward to, this is a quiet yes. If your cat is on a prescription or restricted diet, this is a general treat, not a medical food, so check with your vet before making it a habit. Either way, the tub reseals, so freshness isn't the thing to worry about.
Check today's price on Amazon or Add it to your Amazon cart to sit on it
Before you go
Are Temptations cat treats good for cats?
Yes, in moderation, they're formulated to be 100% nutritionally complete and balanced for adult cats, so an occasional treat isn't nutritionally empty, though they're still a treat, not a meal replacement.
How many Temptations treats can a cat have per day?
Because each treat is under two calories, most cats can have a handful as part of normal daily treating without exceeding their calorie needs, though the right amount depends on your cat's size and regular diet.
Do vets recommend Temptations for cats?
Vets generally consider Temptations fine for occasional treating since it meets complete-and-balanced standards, but they'll still tell you treats should stay a small share of your cat's daily calories.
Full spec sheet
| Brand | Temptations |
|---|---|
| Flavor | Chicken |
| Age Range (Description) | Adult |
| Item Form | Wafer |
| Specific Uses For Product | Treating |
More pet supplies reviews.
Keep comparing
- Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula: Is It Worth It?
Real chicken first, whole grains, and a two-stage nutrient trick most bags don't explain. Here's whether it earns a spot in your dog's bowl. - Ring Outdoor Cam: Is It Worth It for Your Front Door?
You're not buying a camera, you're buying the ten seconds between a noise and knowing what it is. Here's what that's actually worth. - Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks: Worth It?
The smell is the real test of a bully stick. Here's how Natural Farm actually gets rid of it, and whether that's worth paying for.