Is Kirkland oil any good, or just a bigger jar of the same thing?
Worth it, but only if you cook with it often

Why the good coconut oil costs more
You scoop a spoon into a tub of coconut oil that's gone solid on the pantry shelf, working it soft before it'll pour into the pan or the coffee mug. Is Kirkland oil any good, or are you just paying more for a fancier label on the same white block of fat? The doubt shows up right there, spoon in hand, before the oil's even melted.
How cold pressed, unrefined coconut oil actually differs
Here's the mechanism, and it's simpler than the organic sticker makes it look. Cold pressed means the oil is squeezed from fresh coconut meat with heat and pressure alone, no solvents, no bleaching, no deodorizing. That's what unrefined and virgin are actually telling you: the flavor and the coconut smell you get in the jar are the flavor and smell that survived the process, not added back in later. Refined coconut oil strips that character out on purpose so it tastes like nothing, which is fine for some recipes and a letdown for others. The USDA organic certification, verified by OneCert, just confirms the coconuts themselves were grown without synthetic pesticides before any of that pressing happened. What that buys you day to day is a fat that swaps for butter in baking without a chemical aftertaste, holds up fine on a ketogenic plate because it's mostly saturated fat that doesn't need refrigeration, and dissolves into hot coffee the way people expect when they've heard about that style of drink. The pack itself is two 84 ounce tubs, 168 ounces total, and that number matters more than the sticker price: it's the same math as buying rice or flour by the sack instead of the box. Cost per ounce drops hard once you're past a certain size, but only if you'll actually get through it before it turns.
So the real trade isn't organic versus not, it's whether you use enough coconut oil weekly that buying it by the pair makes sense. Two tubs of the same fat cost less per spoonful than one small jar ever will, but only if coconut oil already has a job in your kitchen.
Who the Kirkland coconut oil pack is for, and who should skip it
Worth it if
- you already cook or bake with coconut oil weekly
- you follow a keto or high fat diet
- you want a chemical free substitute for butter
- you have pantry space for two large tubs
Skip it if
- you only need a spoonful now and then
- you dislike the taste and smell of coconut
- you don't have room to store 168 ounces before it turns
Not for anyone who only needs a spoonful of coconut oil once in a while.
Is Kirkland oil any good: the verdict
If coconut oil already shows up in your baking, your coffee, or your keto routine, this is a quiet yes, the bulk math works in your favor. If you'd use half a tub and let the rest go rancid in the back of the cupboard, buy the smaller jar instead and skip the pack.
The real relief here is that once this is in the pantry, you stop thinking about which fat to reach for, baking, sauteing, and coffee all pull from the same tub. Day one looks like popping the lid, smelling actual coconut instead of nothing, and using it without wondering what got stripped out first. Two tubs is a long runway, so there's no rush to ration it, just fold it into what you already cook.
Amazon shoppers rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 793 ratings. That is their number, not ours.
Before you go
Is the oil from Costco good?
Yes, for coconut oil specifically, this Kirkland tub is cold pressed and USDA organic, which puts it in line with pricier boutique brands at a much lower cost per ounce.
Is Kirkland olive oil from Costco real or fake?
That question usually gets asked about Kirkland's olive oil line rather than this coconut oil, but the same principle holds here: Kirkland's private label oils carry real third party certification, in this case OneCert organic, so it isn't an unverified store brand.
Want our verdicts to surface first when you search?
By the numbers
food & drink products reviewedThis one is a yes with a condition attached.
Verdict datasetQuestion indexCC BY 4.0
Full spec sheet
| Product Dimensions | 8 x 6 x 12 inches; 5.25 pounds |
|---|---|
| Units | 168 Fluid Ounces |
| Brand Name | KIRKLAND |
| Import Designation | Made in the USA or Imported |
| Item Form | Oil |
| Specialty | Chemical Free |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Baking |
| Container Type | Tub |
More food & drink reviews.
We also post food & drink verdicts on YouTube.




