Is the Presto FryDaddy electric fryer worth it?
Worth it, if you're frying for a small household
Why deep frying at home never seems to go right
You've stood over a pot of oil on the stovetop, thermometer clipped to the side, watching the temperature climb and dip and climb again while your fries just sit there going pale and greasy. That's the real fight with home frying: heat that won't hold still. Somewhere in the back of your mind is the promise every electric fryer reviews page makes, that a machine could handle the temperature part for you, so frying becomes a Tuesday night thing instead of a special occasion project. You want to believe it, but you've been burned, sometimes literally, by countertop gadgets that promise ease and deliver a mess.
How the Presto FryDaddy controls temperature automatically
Here's what I'd want to know first: the FryDaddy has no dial, no display, nothing to set. That's not a missing feature, it's the whole design. Inside, a thermostat is wired straight to the heating element, so the moment the oil reaches frying temperature the element cycles down, and the moment it drops, say because you just dropped in a batch of cold fries, it cycles back up. You're not managing heat, the machine is holding a single number, so the guesswork that ruins a stovetop pot of oil is gone before it starts. The 4:4 ratio, four cups of oil for four servings, is the other half of the trick. A smaller oil bath heats up and recovers faster than a big pot, which is why this thing goes from cold to frying in a few minutes instead of the fifteen you'd wait on the stove. Less oil also means less to store, less to strain, less to smell up the kitchen for a week. And the ceramic nonstick surface inside and out is the bit the listing buries as an afterthought: cleanup is a wipe, not a scrub, and because there's nothing to worry about leaching, you can let the oil sit under the snap-on lid and reuse it instead of straining it into a jar every time. That's three separate annoyances of home frying, heat, wait, cleanup, solved by the same small pot.
So you're not really buying a fryer, you're buying a thermostat you never have to fuss with. The small oil bath and fast recovery are just what happens when you stop trying to heat a whole stockpot for four servings of fries. The only real question is whether that hands-off crispiness earns a permanent spot on your counter, or a cupboard you'll actually open.
Who the FryDaddy is for, and who should skip it
Worth it if
- you're cooking for two or three people
- you want crispy fries or shrimp without babysitting a pot of oil
- counter and storage space is tight
Skip it if
- you regularly cook for a crowd
- you want to fry large cuts like a whole chicken or turkey
- you need dishwasher safe cleanup
If you cook for a crowd or need to fry whole birds, this compact fryer will only frustrate you.
The Presto FryDaddy verdict: is it worth it
If you're cooking for two or three and want fries or shrimp on a weeknight without a production, this is a quiet yes: it heats fast, holds steady, and wipes clean in a minute. If you're feeding a crowd or want to fry a whole chicken, the compact size and 4 cup oil bath will just get in your way, this one's built for small batches, not big ones.
Picture the version of Tuesday where you just want fries with dinner: oil's hot in a few minutes, the scoop lifts them out golden, and the fryer's cool enough to wipe down before you've even eaten. That's the whole appeal, the babysitting is gone. A lot of buyers land in the same place, praising how fast it heats and how easy it is to clean, though a few notice the temperature working harder once the oil's been going a while, which tracks with any small batch fryer under real use. Either way, the itch for stovetop frying without the thermometer dance is what this actually satisfies.
Amazon shoppers rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 30,345 ratings. That is their number, not ours.
Before you go
How much oil does the Presto FryDaddy actually need?
Just four cups, enough for four servings of fries, thanks to its compact 4:4 oil to food ratio.
Is the Presto FryDaddy dishwasher safe?
No, it should never be fully immersed in water, the ceramic nonstick surface wipes clean by hand instead.
Can you reuse the oil in a FryDaddy after frying?
Yes, the snap on lid lets you store oil right in the fryer between uses without spills or odor.
How long does the Presto FryDaddy take to heat up?
It preheats quickly, typically just a few minutes, since it only has to heat four cups of oil rather than a full pot.
By the numbers
We have reviewed 194 kitchen products. 91% land where this one does: worth it, with a condition attached. Only 9% earn an unconditional yes at full price. Every verdict is published as open data in the Is It Worth It Reviews Verdict Dataset (CC BY 4.0).
Full spec sheet
| Model Name | FryDaddy Electric Deep Fryer - Handy Scoop Included, Snap On Lid, Easy to Clean |
|---|---|
| Brand Name | Presto |
| Unit Count | 1 Count |
| Number of Items | 1 |
| Included Components | Fryer, lid, magnetic plug, and scoop |
| Item Type Name | Deep Fryer |
| Model Number | 05420 |
| Part Number | 05420 |
Keep comparing
More kitchen reviews.
We also post kitchen verdicts on YouTube, Tumblr, Mastodon, Bluesky.