Colour Mill Food ColoringWorth it, if your baking lives in buttercream and chocolate
around $75Buy on Amazon

Is Colour Mill Food Coloring Worth It?

Worth it, if your baking lives in buttercream and chocolate

4/5around $75
Buy on Amazon

1 of 5

You bake buttercream, ganache or chocolate-heavy cakes regularly

Does that sound like you?

Colour Mill — Is Colour Mill Food Coloring Worth It?
The moment

Picture folding a few drops of regular grocery-store food coloring into a bowl of buttercream, watching it streak through in muddy ribbons no matter how long you mix, or worse, watching melted chocolate seize into a grainy clump the second the dye hits it. You add more, hoping for a vivid pink, and the frosting just gets looser and greasier instead. That's the exact moment bakers start googling colour mill food coloring, wondering if an oil-based option actually fixes it.

The mechanism

Here's the bit the listing buries: regular food coloring is water-based, and buttercream, ganache, melted chocolate and cake batter are fat-based. Water and fat don't mix, so the dye either sits on the surface and streaks, or in chocolate's case, seizes the whole batch into a grainy mess. Colour Mill's dye is suspended in oil instead of water, so it disperses straight into whatever fat you're mixing into, no fighting, no separating. That's why it's built specifically for buttercream, Swiss meringue, chocolate, cake batter, ganache and fondant: those are all fat-heavy mediums, and oil-based dye is the one that actually belongs in them. Because there's no water added, you're not thinning your frosting or throwing off a ganache's set, which matters more than it sounds, a few drops of the wrong coloring can turn a stiff buttercream soupy. The Kickstarter pack gives you twenty millilitres each of twelve core shades, from black to hot pink to sky blue, enough to mix your way to almost any color without buying single bottles one at a time. It's allergen-free and vegan, and it meets Australian and New Zealand food safety standards.

The click

So you're not really buying color, you're buying compatibility, a dye built to disperse into fat instead of fighting it. If most of your baking lives in buttercream, ganache or melted chocolate, that compatibility is the whole point, and it's why a small bottle of oil-based dye can outperform a giant water-based set.

Who it's for

Worth it if

  • You bake buttercream, ganache or chocolate-heavy cakes regularly
  • You've had chocolate seize or frosting thin out from regular food coloring
  • You want one pack covering a wide color range instead of buying bottles one at a time

Skip it if

  • Most of your coloring work is royal icing or water-based glazes
  • You only color food occasionally and don't want a dedicated oil-based set
  • You need shades outside this core twelve and would rather buy singles

Not for bakers who mainly work in royal icing or water-based glazes, where a water-based gel already does the job.

The verdict

If you regularly make buttercream, chocolate work or cake batter and you're tired of streaky, thinned-out color, this is a quiet yes, and the twelve-color pack means you won't be buying singles for a while. If you mostly tint royal icing or simple glazes, which are water-based anyway, save your money and stick with what you've got.

Amazon shoppers rate it 4 out of 5 across 10,168 ratings. That is their number, not ours.

Buy on Amazon

Before you go

Is Color Mill sold in stores?

No, Color Mill is mostly sold online rather than stocked widely on craft store shelves.

Does Michaels sell Colour Mill?

Some Michaels locations carry a limited selection, but stock varies by store.

Why is Color Mill so expensive?

Color Mill costs more than typical water-based food coloring because it's oil-dispersed for fat-based mediums like buttercream and chocolate.

By the numbers

8%

earn an unconditional yes at full priceOut of 243 kitchen products we have reviewed. This one is a yes with a condition attached.

Verdict datasetQuestion indexCC BY 4.0

Maya Bennett covers kitchen & home for Is It Worth It Reviews. We research products and explain them honestly; we do not test them and we never pretend to.